Transforming Together
Working to build a resilient network of local practitioners in the North-East to offer a model for how public services could enact change for women with multiple unmet needs.
26 Aug 2024
The Transforming Together network is convened by Agenda Alliance and funded by the Smallwood Trust.
During network meetings, members are developing regional solutions to the systemic challenges that prevent women at the sharpest edge of inequality from accessing support, aiming to implement the recommendations proposed in our 2023 report, Dismantling Disadvantage.
As we approach the network’s fourth meeting, we’ve shared this summary of the network’s journey so far, and some of the key challenges that we face. Learn more about our network and its aims.
Women facing multiple unmet needs are continually pushed towards further harm because they cannot access consistent or meaningful, gender-informed support. At present, there is a chronic mismatch between the services needed and the services available in the North East. While there are increasingly discussions about improving services for women, the network finds that “actions have yet to catch up.”
Transforming Together network memberWomen who don't fit the 'rescue' narrative are being ignored and shut down
One of the major problems is the inconsistency and patchy provision of support for women facing multiple unmet needs. The network describes the North East as a “postcode lottery” with variable responses for those at the sharpest edge of disadvantage. For instance, local authorities give “wildly varying” responses to women with complex needs. However, the network has identified opportunities to coordinate better responses and change for women, including the new North East Mayoral Combined Authority.
Transforming Together network memberThe new mayor could use their convening power to bring together small charities, national services, local authorities, services and women with lived experience.
The fragmented, siloed nature of services in the North East forces women to navigate multiple services simultaneously and prevents vital information sharing. There are cliff-edges and varying thresholds for support; for example, women with a “dual-diagnosis” are often shut out from mental health services. In particular, the divide between adult and children’s social services has been highlighted as a problem, leading to increasing numbers of mothers having their children removed from their care.
Transforming Together network memberThe left hand has no idea what the right hand is doing.
Across services, the network currently describes a “risk averse” culture that is instinctively punitive; for example, “mothers are held responsible for protecting their children from perpetrators, rather than being protected themselves.” At the same time, women often face stigma and scrutiny, which furthers their distrust in services. As a result, it is difficult for women facing multiple unmet needs to build trusting relationships with practitioners in services. They are described as “hard to reach” but, in reality, there is not a concerted efforted across services to reach them.
Transforming Together network memberIt's broken that there's victim blaming of women, especially around child removal, leading to the removal of a woman from her home, rather than the perpetrator.
Transforming Together network memberWomen's sentencing needs to be looked at (especially around the sex work narrative) and [finding] her voice against the criminal who commits acts against her because he knows that he can get away with it.
Nevertheless, there are many practitioners and services striving to make a difference to women’s lives; in particular, specialist services that work with women within their communities. The importance of these charities was underlined: they build trusting relationships with women and provide environments in which they feel safe. However, given the pressure on public services, there is a sense that the system has become “too reliant on charities” who are themselves increasingly struggling to secure funding.
Transforming Together network memberCharities have little ability to commit to long term sustainable funding and services.
There are many barriers that prevent specialist services from being commissioned and recognized for their role. The network is concerned that, despite this work being preventative (with downstream economic savings to the public purse), specialist charities struggle to “prove” their impact to funders. As such, the network would like to see “better funding opportunities for smaller charities whose results can't be immediately quantified.” Part of this should include larger charities giving up some of their power and “sharing expertise about grant funding applications as they have the knowledge and resources.”
Transforming Together network memberHow can you demonstrate the money saved from something that hasn’t yet happened?
While there is a lot of innovation at the “systems-level”, it doesn’t seem to be engaging with frontline staff and those going through the system in any way. Consequently, there is a desire within the network for “collective action” and “collective power” to drive change and “shift the dial” on services. The network recognises that this will also necessitate redistribution of power. Part of this necessitates lived experience involvement, which needs to be intentionally incorporated. Currently, across the system, there is a “lack of lived experience voices being heard (truly heard).” The network seeks to respond to this and champion lived experience engagement and involvement.
Transforming Together network memberSmall organisations and services are needed. Women feel safe in these services.
Transforming Together network member[One opportunity for change is to] tell people's true experiences and stories […] not just the headlines people see about women in the media, their whole story and experience that have led to now.
Working to build a resilient network of local practitioners in the North-East to offer a model for how public services could enact change for women with multiple unmet needs.
In advance of the elections for the new Mayor of the North East, we explain what devolution is, and how it relates to women and girls.
In the context of a new government, our Policy and Public Affairs Officer shares an update on how we're approaching our work in the North East.